Saturday, February 1, 2020

Table Talk Snapshots Round 1


Our first round of Table Talks for TMC6 papers is complete!  

While this blogger wasn't able to capture all of the wonderful discussions taking place, here's a snapshot of two collaborative conversations that took place.



Some snippets from a table discussion of the paper include:

“The biggest obstacle is teachers wondering how do I keep kids safe?” A safety guide and having conversations with students before they participate in the chat help with this. Every discussion starts with setting norms created by students.

People collaborate in different ways. Kids are watching, listening, and participating with the opportunity over the entire month to continue the conversations through "slow chats" and choose to participate in a variety of ways; there are lots of different entry points.

Having one expert adult online can really help prompt thinking among students.

This paper is helpful in advocating for positive use of personal devices and social media for students in areas and schools where there is a movement to ban personal devices.

The growth in students who participate in the ways they express themselves online is an amazing journey. 

Discussion of social media platforms, perceptions of Twitter, and whether students interested in using other platforms. “It has to be organic” - students should decide what that looks like, what the commitment level is, and how they will use it.

It can be so very validating for students to see their ideas engaged with.

Students have the option to participate in chats without sharing any identifiable personal information if teachers facilitate.

Connections Between Campuses: Creating a Collaborative OCULA/OSLA Information Literacy Toolkit by Heather Buchansky 




















Snippets from a table discussion of the paper include:

This information literacy toolkit aims to begin a conversation about bridging the gap between secondary and post-secondary staff with the common goal of helping students develop research skills that will help them succeed.

Some participants at post-secondary institutions have identified gaps and start by asking whether students have used school or public libraries.

Outreach initiatives can be one solution.

Teachers, teacher-librarians, post-secondary instructors and post-secondary library staff should all be part of the conversation.

How do we go about identifying skills students need? “The more humans you have involved and the more diversity of perspectives, the more helpful.”

Different teachers come to the LLC different amounts, which can result in inequities for students who may have inconsistent experiences within schools. How do teacher-librarians facilitate this in a realistic way?

How scalable are our solutions? What’s sustainable?

What about schools that don’t have a post-secondary institution nearby?

What can be done online, on paper, in person, and what requires every student on a computer?

How can we show warmth to address library anxiety?  Would short videos or webinars be accessible solutions? Can they have the warmth factor?

Discussion of mandatory library instruction in post-secondary and attaching a credit or value to it.

How many students would take a library instruction course as an elective? People don’t know what they don’t know.


The Eric Walters School Library Summer Lending Challenge: Findings from the Research

A survey of quantitative and qualitative questions was sent to all participants in the Eric Walters School Library Summer Lending Challenge and the conclusion is that we need to set the books free and lend books for the summer! 

Can summer lending programs in Canada's school libraries be successful?  If so, what factors can contribute to this success?



111 schools responded to the survey representing at total of 4365 students who borrowed 28,042 books.  

The response was overwhelmingly positive and 43% of schools reported no book losses.

3 key themes emerged from the survey:

  • Access 
  • Choice
  • Trust
The program will run again this year with earlier promotion!



What can you do at your school, in your school district, or in your association?  

Comment on the paper or share on social media using #TMCanada2020 


Read the paper for specific recommendations for school libraries and school library professionals: The Eric Walters School Library Summer Lending Challenge: Findings from the Research by Anita Brooks Kirkland and Carol Koechlin 

Building Connections: Assessment

What should assessment look like, sound like and feel like in the Library Learning Commons?

Check out the results of our table discussions below and share your thoughts here in the comments or on Twitter using #TMCanada2020. 













Spotlight Speakers: Garfield Gini-Newman and Laura Gini-Newman



Garfield and Laura Gini-Newman began the day by sharing new thinking from their paper, Powerful Instruction and Powerful Assessment: The Double-Helix of Learningbased on ideas shaped by their experiences working with teachers and students around the world.  

What started as a Tweet was meant to become a short article for CSLJ, which evolved into this paper.

Central to this paper is the distinction between assessment, "to sit alongside a learner," and evaluation, "to judge a learner."  The thinking is about how we move from sitting in judgement to sitting alongside, and how feedback can become guidance.

Garfield and Laura use a double helix analogy - the strands of instruction and assessment are seamlessly intertwined and are held together at the core by relationships.  How do we use tools and instructional strategies to make this a reality? 

They suggest starting with thinking as the foundation. Through iterative learning, the story grows as we learn.  Encourage students at important moments in their learning process to stop, pause, and reflect.  Rather than reflecting back, have students reflect forward and consider how what they've learned will move them forward.




The speakers highlighted four innovations to use as metacognitive tools for students:

  • Launches to initiate thinking
  • Cascading challenges - what is the natural sequence of thinking students will have to go through in order to be able to solve this problem? 
  • Thoughtbooks - a safe place for students to park ideas
  • Guides to Success - an alternative to traditional rubrics

Now, Garfield and Laura want to hear from you - what should next steps for this thinking look like?  

Read the paper: Powerful Instruction and Powerful Assessment: The Double-Helix of Learning by Garfield Gini-Newman and Laura Gini-Newman